|
| Measuring
Progress |
| Sep
30th 2009, Jayati
Ghosh |
|
| The
limitations of GDP and HDI that are used as standard
measurements of growth and development might have prompted
President Nicolas Sarkozy to set up a commission to
look into alternative ways of measuring economic and
social progress. However, the report of the commission,
instead of making much headway, has added to the existing
debate, thereby leaving some of the most crucial questions
unanswered. |
|
| Assessing
the Recent West Bengal Experience |
| Mar
20th 2009, Jayati
Ghosh |
|
| A
report prepared by Indicus Analytics on the economic
development of West Bengal tries to portray a dismal
performance of the state with regard to growth, employment,
poverty reduction, health etc. The article tries to
question the findings of the report and argues that
in many counts West Bengal has performed much better
than the national average. |
|
| Health
Imbalances |
| Mar
5th 2009, Jayati
Ghosh |
|
| While
India has one of the worst health indicators in the
world, there is a paucity of ideas and initiatives to
take care of the problem of health. The recent Report
of the Independent Commission on Development and Health
in India shows the imbalances with regard to health
indicators in the country and makes important recommendations
to fix the ailing public health system. |
|
| Where
have all the footpaths gone? |
| Feb
3rd 2009, Jayati
Ghosh |
|
| The
author puts forward a new definition of underdevelopment
in terms of lack of amenities for pedestrians in towns
and cities. Although the problems of urban slums have
been discussed in the context of rapid urbanisation,
the importance of having safe, continuous and usable
walking spaces, which are almost lacking in many urban
sprawls across the developing world, seems to be missed
out. |
|
| The
Loss of Development Finance |
| Oct
23rd 2008, Jayati
Ghosh |
|
| The
financial tsunami that is now threatening to engulf
many developing countries as well, makes all the more
clear the dangers posed by unregulated financial markets.
As is known, in addition to creating the conditions
for greater fragility, financial liberalisation generates
a bias towards deflationary macroeconomic policies and
forces the state to adopt a deflationary stance to appease
financial interests. In fact, financial liberalisation
in developing countries has even worse consequences,
because it can retard or even reverse the development. |
|
| Recent
Growth in West Bengal |
| May
12th
2008, C. P. Chandrasekhar & Jayati Ghosh |
|
| The
state of West Bengal has been the focus of national
discussion because of the various implications of its
proposed industrialisation policy. In this article the
authors consider the background to this policy by analysing
the most recent available evidence on growth trends
in West Bengal. |
|
| Digital
Dumps: A Growing Threat for Developing Countries
|
| Mar
17th 2008,
Jayati
Ghosh |
|
The
management of huge and growing quantities of electronic
waste may emerge as one of the more important environmental
problems of developing countries in the near future.
The problems arise from the very significant health
and environmental hazards associated with e-waste. As
usual, this impact is worse in developing countries,
where people often live in close proximity to dumps
or landfills of untreated e-waste. |
|
| Unravelling
India's Growth Transition |
| Nov
2nd
2007, C.P. Chandrasekhar |
| India's
GDP growth has experienced a sudden boost in the middle
of 2003. One specific component of the services sector,
and interestingly, manufacturing growth seems to have
contributed significantly to this transition in growth
pattern. But the fact that the domestic market, which
played a major role in this scenario, was driven in
the final analysis by a financial boom that eased credit
availability, reduced interest rates and encouraged
debt-financed consumption and investment, makes the
growth process fragile and a cause for concern for future
policymaking. |
|
| Dealing
with Short-Term Migration |
| Oct
4th 2007, C. P. Chandrasekhar & Jayati Ghosh |
|
|
Short-term
migration for work has evidently increased rapidly in
recent times in India, but our statistical systems are
currently not adequate to capture such flows of labour.
In this edition of MacroScan, C. P. Chandrasekhar and
Jayati Ghosh discuss the limitations of the existing
data, the tendencies that do emerge and the policy implications
of short-term economic migration. |
|
| Incorporation
and Exclusion by the Indian State |
| Oct
3rd 2007, Jayati Ghosh |
| The
development project is nowhere near completion in India
and a major reason is that a basic feature of the process
of economic development thus far has been exclusion
in various forms. Exploring the reasons why and how
requires looking into the relationship between the state
and economic development and the class character of
the state which has undergone major changes over this
period and assumed much more complex and multidimensional
forms. |
|
| ''Two
Nations'' |
| Sep
3rd 2007, Prabhat Patnaik |
|
|
Neo-liberalism
has spawned a more plausible division of the country
into two ''nations'', a term that may not stand up to
strict scrutiny under the canons of Marxist theory,
but nonetheless contains a rich description, reminiscent
of Lenin, of the Indian context. One of these two nations,
the ''nation of the rich'', believes that it belongs
to the first world, while the other, ''the nation of
the poor'', remains stuck in the third world, experiencing
agrarian crisis, unemployment, and privations on account
of cuts in government expenditures, that pervade the
entire third world. |
|
| The
Potential Fall-out of Basel II |
| Mar
17th 2007, C.P Chandrasekhar and Jayati Ghosh |
|
|
Continuing
with the discussion on Basel II and India's banking
structure, the authors argue that using external ratings
to decide the appropriate risk-weights to assess capital
adequacy inevitably leads banks to decide their lending
patterns based on pure profit considerations. This makes
it difficult to simultaneously implement a banking policy
that seeks to direct a proportion of lending to specified
sectors for meeting growth and equity objectives. |
|
| Basel
II and India's Banking Structure |
| Mar
3rd 2007, C.P. Chandrasekhar and Jayati Ghosh |
|
|
Despite
the postponement of the target dates for banks to implement
the Basel II guidelines, adjustments aimed at realizing
that goal are underway. In this and the following article,
the authors examine what the guidelines involve, their
effects on banking structure and behaviour and some
likely outcomes of implementing them. |
|
| An
Aspect of Neo-liberalism |
| Dec
19th 2006, Prabhat Patnaik |
|
The
increase in the scale of social ''bribes'' which governments
have to offer capitalists in order to elicit investment
from them is an important feature of neo-liberalism.
Currently, the Indian nation state as well as its different
state governments are experiencing this. Because of
its impact on state finances, this has crucial implications
for the poor and the working masses. |
|
| Being
Your Own Boss |
| Dec
18th 2006, Jayati Ghosh |
|
Around
half of the work force in India currently does not work
for a direct employer not only in agriculture, but increasingly
in a wide range of non-agricultural activities. This
significance of self-employment brings home the urgent
need to consider basic social security that covers not
just hired workers in the unorganised sector, but also
those who typically work for themselves. |
|
| Development
as a Nobel Cause |
| Oct
30th 2006, Jayati Ghosh |
|
The
award of the Nobel Peace Prize for 2006 jointly to Muhammad
Yunus, the recognised creator of the ''microcredit''
model of finance for the poor shows the Nobel Committee's
recognition that peace is not really possible without
more equitable development. The most engaging aspect
of Muhammad Yunus' contributions lies in his flexible
approach to looking for new solutions for meeting the
needs of the poor. |
|
| A
Foreign Hand for Higher Education |
| Sep
28th 2006, C.P. Chandrasekhar |
|
While
considering demands from more well-to-do sections in
the country for domestic access to the services of foreign
educational providers, the government needs to assess
the private and social benefits of acceding to this
demand after taking into account the social costs that
such a policy may entail. Making a commitment under
GATS could tie the hands of the government. |
|
| The
Assault of Vulgar Economy |
| Sep
11th 2006, Prabhat Patnaik |
|
To
remain confined to the ''thingness'' of economic categories
without reference to the social relations of which they
were simultaneously the expression, was ''vulgar economy''
according to Karl Marx. Almost a century and a half
after his painstaking work had unearthed the anatomy
of modern bourgeois society, we are once more in the
danger of being deluged by ''vulgar economy'', manifest
in the contemporary Indian discourse on the farmers'
suicides, GDP growth rate and poverty reduction, etc. |
|
| Fallacies
and Silences in the Approach to the Eleventh Plan |
| Jul
26th 2006, C.P. Chandrasekhar and Jayati Ghosh |
|
In
this paper, the authors look at the specific proposals
made in the Planning Commission's Approach Paper to
the Eleventh Plan in the areas of control over and loss
of land, employment generation, agriculture and food
security, health and education. The paper questions
the underlying perception that creating a profitable
environment for private sector functioning will be enough
to fulfil most social goals, and no particular planning
strategy is required for this. |
|
| The
Need to Protect Petty Production |
| Jul
17th 2006, Prabhat Patnaik |
|
This paper
argues that in a situation where unemployment is generated
through the disappearance of small-scale production,
the ''efficiency'' argument in favour of their closure
does not stand, even if small-scale units are more inefficient
at the micro-level. The destruction of petty production
through exposure to liberal trade, in the name of efficiency,
is therefore an undesirable course of action. |
|
| The
Children of Migrant Workers |
| Jun
03rd 2006, Jayati Ghosh |
|
Given
the dangers involved in allowing the neglect of migrant
workers to continue, it is absolutely imperative for
both society at large and government policy in particular,
to make the issue of basic protection for migrant families
and the provision of public services and systems for
migrants, including children, a basic priority.
|
|
| Agriculture's
Role in Contemporary Development |
| May
23rd 2006, C.P. Chandrasekhar and Jayati Ghosh |
|
While
GDP growth in India is touching new highs, the divergence
in sectoral growth rates only increases. While industry
and, particularly, services record creditable or remarkable
rates of growth, the agricultural sector performs poorly.
In this article, C.P. Chandrasekhar and Jayati Ghosh
discuss some implications of this disproportionality. |
|
| Making
the Employment Guarantee Work |
| May
20th 2006, Jayati Ghosh |
|
An
ongoing process of mobilisation and social audit that
is taking place in the Dungarpur district of Rajasthan
shows how the rural employment programme can indeed
be made to work. But, given that the Central Government
has started going slow in terms of making available
the necessary funds transfers, vigilance is required
even in terms of monitoring the Central Government.
|
|
| The
Diffusion of Development |
| Feb
18th 2006, Prabhat Patnaik |
|
In
this article, the author discusses the Baran hypothesis
that there cannot be a spontaneous diffusion of industrial
development from the developed world to the countries
of the third world under capitalism: a hypothesis apparently
contradicted by the current pattern of development visible
at least in Asia. His analysis resolves this contradiction
by using an inherent but less talked about 'contradictions
to capitalism' which is the role of a stable medium
of wealth or in the present context, a leading currency.
He explains why the current pattern of growth and technology
diffusion in the newly industrialising countries cannot
be sustained given the necessary pattern of their interaction
with the leading capitalist country. |
|
| Why
Jaani can't Spell: |
| Jan
25th 2006, Jayati Ghosh |
|
The
erosion of language skills in India has implications
which go far beyond mere economic disadvantages. It
extends to more worrying effects upon our ability as
a society for introspection and creative reflection. |
|
|
Archives >> |
| |